.png)
Introduction
Debt mutual funds are widely
marketed as safe and stable investment options, particularly for conservative
investors seeking steady returns without the volatility of equities. Yet,
recent market conditions have shown that even these so-called “safe”
investments are not immune to losses. Rising interest rates, credit downgrades,
and liquidity challenges have triggered negative returns in several categories
of debt funds. This trend is a reminder for retail investors, businesses, and
financial planners that understanding the risks behind debt instruments is as
crucial as with equity funds.
Background:
Why Debt Funds Are Considered ‘Safe’
Debt mutual funds primarily invest
in fixed-income instruments such as government securities (G-Secs), corporate
bonds, treasury bills, and money market instruments. The general perception is
that since these funds deal with “debt,” they carry lower risk than
equity-oriented mutual funds.
Historically, investors—especially
those in higher tax brackets—have used debt funds as an efficient vehicle to
park short- to medium-term money. Benefits like indexation on long-term capital
gains (before taxation rules changed in April 2023), relative stability, and
diversification from equities made them a preferred choice.
However, “safety” in debt funds has
always been a relative concept. Unlike a fixed deposit (FD), where returns are
guaranteed, mutual fund performance is market-linked. Key risks that can affect
debt funds include:
- Interest Rate Risk:
Bond prices fall when interest rates rise.
- Credit Risk:
Possibility of default or downgrade of bonds held.
- Liquidity Risk:
Difficulty in selling debt instruments during stress.
- Duration Risk:
Long-term funds are more sensitive to rate changes.
This is why debt funds, despite
their reputation, can sometimes deliver negative returns—a situation
that shocks retail investors who expect stability.
Why
Debt Mutual Funds Are Showing Negative Returns
1.
Impact of Rising Interest Rates
When interest rates go up, the price
of existing bonds falls because new bonds offer better yields. Debt funds
holding long-duration papers see an immediate drop in Net Asset Value (NAV).
For instance, if a 10-year G-Sec
yielding 6% was bought earlier, and new issuances start yielding 7%, the older
bond loses value in the secondary market.
2.
Credit Risk and Corporate Defaults
Debt funds that invested in
lower-rated corporate bonds for higher yields face the danger of default. The
IL&FS crisis in 2018 and Franklin Templeton’s debt fund freeze in 2020 are
reminders of how credit events can erode investor wealth.
3.
Liquidity Pressures
In stressed markets, debt
instruments can become difficult to sell. When investors redeem units in large
numbers, fund managers are forced to sell securities at a loss, further
reducing NAVs.
4.
Policy and Regulatory Changes
- In April 2023, indexation benefits on long-term
debt funds were removed. This reduced post-tax attractiveness.
- SEBI has also tightened risk disclosures, categorization,
and valuation rules, which expose real-time volatility.
5.
Global and Domestic Macro Factors
- Rising U.S. Treasury yields and global bond sell-offs
spill over into Indian debt markets.
- Inflation concerns and RBI’s monetary policy stance
also play a decisive role.
Impact
Analysis
Who
Is Affected?
- Retail Investors:
Short-term negative returns can shock conservative savers, especially
those shifting from bank FDs.
- Corporates & HNIs: Firms using debt funds for treasury management face
volatility in cash flow planning.
- Fund Managers:
Pressure to balance liquidity, yield, and risk without compromising
safety.
Practical
Implications
- For Businesses:
- Debt fund volatility can impact short-term treasury
operations.
- Firms may reconsider debt funds for working capital
parking.
- For Taxpayers:
- Loss of indexation benefits makes debt funds less
tax-efficient compared to the past.
- Short-term gains are taxed at slab rates, making FDs
more attractive for some investors.
- For Auditors & CAs:
- Need to carefully classify and value corporate debt
fund investments.
- Must advise clients on real risks and diversification
strategies.
Common
Misunderstandings
- “Debt funds never lose money.”
False. They carry market-linked risks. - “NAV will always rise steadily.”
No. Rising interest rates can cause NAV erosion. - “Corporate bonds are as safe as government bonds.”
Not true. G-Secs have sovereign backing; corporate papers carry credit risk. - “Short-term funds are risk-free.”
Even liquid and ultra-short funds can face redemption or liquidity stress.
Expert
Commentary
As per senior financial analyst
Ramesh Krishnan, “Debt funds are stable in the long run, but investors must
accept that short-term fluctuations are part of the journey. Safety in debt is
relative—it depends on credit quality, fund duration, and macroeconomic
conditions. Blindly treating them as FD alternatives is dangerous.”
Conclusion
& Action Steps
Debt mutual funds remain an
important part of a diversified portfolio, but the myth of them being
“risk-free” needs to be broken. Investors must:
- Align investment horizon with fund duration.
- Choose high-credit-quality funds, even if yields are
lower.
- Diversify across equity, debt, and hybrid products.
- Regularly review portfolio performance with an advisor.
For businesses and HNIs, treasury
allocation must factor in potential NAV volatility. CAs and auditors should
ensure clients are fully aware of both taxation changes and market risks.
Going forward, market experts expect
continued volatility in bond yields, especially if inflation persists.
Investors should treat debt funds as medium- to long-term vehicles, not
quick-return instruments.
FAQs
1. Can debt mutual funds give
negative returns?
Yes. Rising interest rates, credit downgrades, or liquidity pressures can cause
NAVs to fall, resulting in short-term losses.
2. Are debt funds safer than equity
funds?
They are less volatile than equities but not risk-free. Risks differ: equity
carries market risk; debt carries interest rate and credit risk.
3. Should I stop investing in debt
funds now?
Not necessarily. If your horizon matches the fund’s maturity profile, you can
hold through volatility. Switching entirely to FDs may reduce long-term
returns.
4. How can I minimize risk in debt
funds?
Stick to short-duration funds during rising interest rate cycles, prefer
high-credit-quality funds, and diversify.
5. What tax rules apply to debt
funds now?
Since April 2023, capital gains on debt funds are taxed as per income tax
slabs, regardless of holding period. No indexation benefit is available.
References
/ Source Links
- SEBI Mutual Fund Regulations
- RBI Monetary Policy Updates
- AMFI India – Debt Funds Basics
- Ministry of Finance – Tax Updates